Wood Garage Doors? Or Composite Garage Door? Which Is Better?

Wood Garage Doors

Choosing a suitable material for your garage door can be a tough decision. Composite and wood are both popular options, each with unique benefits. This article will compare these materials to help you make an informed choice.

Key Takeaways

  • Composite garage doors are more affordable and low-maintenance than wood doors, making them a cost-effective choice for many homeowners. They also resist warping, cracking, chipping, rotting, and insect damage.
  • Wood garage doors provide a classic and stylish appearance that can boost the curb appeal of any home. However, they are more expensive and require more upkeep due to their susceptibility to weather conditions and potential for structural damage.
  • Wood and Composite garage doors offer multiple design options, allowing homeowners to find styles that effectively complement their homes. Whether looking for modern or traditional designs, both materials have many choices.
  • Your area’s climate plays a significant role in deciding between wood and steel garage doors. Steel is ideal for extreme weather conditions, while wood offers better insulation but might need extra care in humid areas.
  • Considering the long-term value alongside initial costs is crucial when choosing between wood and steel garage doors. While steel may be less expensive upfront, wooden doors can add aesthetic value to your property if appropriately maintained.

Pros and Cons of Wood Garage Doors

Wood doors offer a classic and stylish appearance but are more expensive and may require more maintenance than steel doors. They are often made from materials like cedar or redwood, which are naturally beautiful and can enhance the overall look of your home. These doors can be customized with various finishes, stains, and designs to match your home’s style and architecture.
However, wood garage doors can require regular maintenance, such as staining or painting, to protect them from the elements and prevent warping or cracking. They may also need to be regularly cleaned and inspected for any signs of damage or wear.
Additionally, wood doors can be more prone to scratches, dents, and other damage than composite doors. They may also be more susceptible to insect infestations or rot if improperly maintained.
Overall, while wood garage doors offer a timeless and elegant aesthetic, they come with a higher upfront cost and may require more maintenance over time. It’s crucial to weigh the benefits and drawbacks of wood garage doors before deciding on your home.

Classic and stylish appearance

Wooden garage doors bring a timeless elegance to any home, boosting curb appeal and adding character. Their classic and stylish appearance sets them apart from other materials, offering a warm and inviting look that can complement various architectural styles.

These doors are not just about aesthetics; they also provide a sturdy frame and strong panels that contribute to their overall appeal.

Opting for wooden garage doors means choosing a design that repels scratches easily, maintaining its elegant look over time. Whether you prefer the natural beauty of wood grains or a painted finish, these doors offer unique customization options to match your style.

Their distinct charm is undeniable, making them an excellent choice for homeowners looking to enhance their property’s exterior with beauty and functionality.

Higher cost

Wooden garage doors are undoubtedly appealing and bring an element of sophistication to any residence, but they are more expensive than steel garage doors. This price difference is primarily due to the premium materials used in constructing wooden doors and the skilled craftsmanship involved in their production.
Moreover, wooden garage doors may demand more upkeep, which adds to their overall cost compared to steel options. Nevertheless, despite the higher price, wooden garage doors offer a classic charm and can significantly boost the exterior appearance of your home.
For homeowners on a budget, composite garage doors offer a more economical choice. This material is generally more affordable than wood and requires minimal maintenance.

It may require more maintenance.

Wooden garage doors may need more upkeep than steel ones, as their natural material makes them prone to warping, cracking, chipping, rotting, and insect damage.
Regular painting or staining is essential for maintaining the appearance of wooden garage doors and protecting them from weather conditions. Additionally, thorough inspections are necessary to detect any signs of wear and tear and prevent potential structural issues.
The care required for wooden garage doors goes beyond aesthetics, as they need special attention to address their vulnerabilities. These unique pieces of craftsmanship add character and value to a property but also require tailored maintenance to ensure longevity and durability.

Advantages of Composite Garage Doors

Composite garage doors offer many advantages over solid wood and metal overhead doors. You’ll quickly notice the low maintenance required for composite doors. They don’t need to be sanded, painted, or stained like wood doors. With a fiberglass facing, composite doors are resistant to dents and other damage, making them a durable option for your garage. The R-value of composite doors is typically higher than standard wood doors, providing better insulation for your garage. Additionally, composite garage doors come in various styles, from carriage-style to modern designs, so you can choose one that fits the look of your home and neighborhood. If you’re facing a DIY garage door installation, composite doors are easier to handle than solid wood doors and wood overhead doors as they are lighter and come with a seal coat already applied. Many professional builders and homeowners recommend composite garage doors for their clean appearance, easy maintenance, and extended warranty.

Cons of Composite Garage Doors

While composite garage doors have many advantages, there are also drawbacks. One potential downside is the higher upfront cost than standard wood or metal overhead doors. Although composite garage doors are more durable than wood doors, they may not have the same aesthetic appeal as solid wood or carriage-style doors. Depending on the availability of colors and styles, you may have limited options when choosing a composite garage door. Another factor to consider is the maintenance required for a composite door. While it is lower than a wood door, you may still need to clean and seal the door regularly to maintain its appearance and resistance to damage.

Durable and low-maintenance

Steel garage doors provide long-lasting quality and require minimal maintenance compared to wooden doors. Composite doors, known for their sturdy build, are resistant to warping, cracking, chipping, rotting, and insect damage.
This long-lasting quality of composite doors results in a prolonged lifespan as they are designed to withstand weather conditions without wearing out. Additionally, their low maintenance requirements make them an appealing choice for homeowners seeking a hassle-free option that offers lasting value.
Steel’s strong nature also means it is less prone to scratches or dents, allowing it to maintain its sleek appearance over time with little effort from the homeowner.

More cost-effective

Composite garage doors are recognized for their cost-effectiveness compared to wood garage doors. They need less upkeep and have a longer lifespan, resulting in decreased long-term expenses.
Steel is a more accessible material, making it more straightforward to discover budget-friendly options that offer durability and security. Moreover, steel garage doors offer superior insulation, potentially leading to energy savings and lower utility bills than wooden ones.
Steel garage doors are cost-effective because of their lower initial cost, minimal maintenance needs, and energy-efficient characteristics.

Multiple design options

Composite garage doors have various design options, from modern to traditional styles. Homeowners can add custom colors, finishes, and decorative hardware to match their preferences.
Steel doors with insulation come in different panel designs, including flush, raised, or recessed options that complement various architectural styles.
Wooden garage doors offer various design options, such as carriage houses or contemporary styles. They can be personalized with windows in different shapes and sizes to enhance the charm and character of any home exterior.

Factors to Consider when Choosing a Garage Door

Consider your budget and the climate of your area, as well as the curb appeal you desire when selecting a garage door. It’s important to consider how well the door will insulate your garage, mainly if you use it as a storage space or if it’s attached to your home. Consider the general product features, such as floor elevation, tool compatibility, and ease of ownership and maintenance. If you would look great with a mahogany finish, that’s something to remember when deciding. Before purchasing, read up on reviews and get recommendations from others who have gone through a similar replacement process.

Doors also come in various styles and materials, so choose one that suits your needs and climate best. If insulation and energy efficiency are not a significant concern, a more basic metal door would be sufficient. On the other hand, if you want the added insulating feature, an insulated kit might be the way to go. Remember that the upfront cost of a higher-quality door may be worth the investment in the long run, especially if it isn’t something you plan on replacing often.


Budget plays a significant role when deciding on a garage door material. Steel garage doors are generally more cost-effective than wood ones, making them a practical choice for those looking to save money.

Conversely, wooden garage doors have a higher price tag due to their premium materials and timeless aesthetic appeal. When considering the initial investment, it’s also essential to factor in the long-term maintenance costs .

Steel doors require less upkeep over time so that they may present lower overall costs than wooden doors. Additionally, while wood garage doors can add value and curb appeal to a property, it’s essential to weigh the upfront expenses against the potential returns when deciding which type of door fits your budget constraints.


When choosing a garage door material, the climate must be considered. Steel garage doors are highly durable in various weather conditions, making them an excellent option for extremely hot or cold regions. They are also resistant to warping, cracking, and rotting caused by changes in moisture and temperature.
Alternatively, wooden garage doors offer natural insulation benefits and better thermal performance in mild climates. However, they may need more upkeep in humid or damp areas to prevent warping and decay.
When deciding on the best garage door for your needs, consider how the local climate will affect its durability and performance.

Curb appeal

Wood garage doors are well-known for enhancing a property’s overall appearance. Their warm and natural look provides a timeless charm that can significantly improve any home’s curb appeal.
Wood garage doors’ genuine and welcoming appearance can add character and value to your property, making them an appealing choice for homeowners who want to leave a lasting impression.
When considering the impact on curb appeal, it’s essential to consider all aspects of materials when selecting a garage door that complements your home. Whether you choose wooden or steel garage doors, each material offers unique qualities that can enhance the exterior design of your residence.


When deciding between wood and steel garage doors, it’s essential to weigh the benefits of each material against your specific needs and preferences. Consider maintenance, durability, cost, and the aesthetic appeal a new garage door will bring to your home.

Both wood and steel and composite garage doors have their benefits.

Garage doors made of wood and steel have their benefits. Composite garage doors are long-lasting, require minimal upkeep, and are budget-friendly. They also offer a variety of design choices to accommodate various tastes.
In contrast, wooden garage doors enhance the property’s value and appearance, providing strong structures and better insulation than steel doors. Each material has its advantages, so it is essential to consider personal requirements and financial considerations when choosing the type of garage door to purchase.

Consider your personal preferences and needs when making a decision.

Consider your preferences and needs when deciding between wood and steel garage doors. Consider the climate in your area to determine the level of insulation required for your garage.
Consider the amount of maintenance you are willing to dedicate, as wooden doors typically need more upkeep than steel doors. Evaluate the overall attractiveness of each door material and how it fits in with the style and appearance of your property.
Lastly, factor in your budget restrictions and expectations for long-term value. These considerations will help you choose a garage door that suits your requirements and preferences.
When choosing a garage door, it is crucial to consider factors such as budget, climate, maintenance needs, design options, durability, and insulation capabilities based on your circumstances.

Does a New Garage Door Increase My Home Value?

Calculating the Returns: Garage Door Replacement ROI Analysis Understanding Home Value To comprehend how a new garage door can affect your home's value, it's essential to first understand the factors that influence home value and the importance of curb appeal. Factors...

Garage Door Replacement Cost

Replacing a worn-out or damaged garage door can significantly enhance the security and appearance of your home. If you're considering a garage door replacement but are unsure about the cost, the After Hours Garage Door experts in St. Joseph, MN, have all the...

Emergency Garage Door Repair

When your garage door breaks unexpectedly, it's more than just an inconvenience; it requires immediate contact with professionals who provide garage door emergency repair services. Every year, thousands face this sudden issue, disrupting daily life. Our comprehensive...

Types of Garage Doors

Are you planning to install a new garage door for your home or business? If so, it's crucial to understand the different types of garage doors available in the market. The right garage door can enhance your property's curb appeal, increase value, and provide...

Brands we service and repair

Our technicians can install or repair nearly every type of garage door product and part. We work regularly with quality brands such as Chamberlain, Genie, Haas, Wayne Dalton, and many more.
wayne dalton logo 1 1 300x46 1
haas logo 1 1
beamup logo 1 1
Genie garage door parts logo 1 1
Chamberlain logo 500px 1 1 300x22 1
craftsman logo 400PX 1 1 300x47 1
liftmaster logo 1 1
north central

Need A Free Estimate?

We can provide a free estimate for most types of handyman services. Chat with us Live or Call us for an estimate.
modern garage doors installer 1 1 1024x682 1
Skip to content